Declaration - In a nutshell

It is the 250th anniversary of the Declaration and the founding of the nation, so it is an opportune time to revisit this momentous event. I have found that very few people have actually read the Declaration of Independence—most especially those in elected office. Having taught it for years, I spent the early part of my career writing about what the textbooks get wrong. We generally do a very poor job as historians and textbook authors in telling the story of the Declaration.

For example, we celebrate July 4th as Independence Day, but it was actually July 2nd when they voted for independence. On July 3rd, John Adams wrote his wife Abigail a letter saying that generations of Americans for all of history to come would be celebrating July 2nd as Independence Day. Poor John Adams. Congress approved it on July 4th, but July 2nd is the true Independence Day.

We also know little about the writing of it. Thomas Jefferson spent seventeen days in a second-story loft at the Graff House in Philadelphia working on the draft. He gets all the credit, but a good chunk of the Declaration was removed or added largely by Ben Franklin. By any objective measure, Franklin's edits were considerable upgrades to Jefferson's work. Yet Jefferson complained that Franklin mangled his genius, and he spent much of the rest of his life whining and complaining about it. But it was Franklin's work that made it a vastly better document. 

If you could take a time machine and go back to 1775, or even June of 1776, and talk to the founders and talk to people, you'd find that the lion's share of them favored reconciliation, not what they called independency. It was almost a "Hail Mary," fourth-quarter kind of thing—a very unlikely scenario. These are just some of the big stories that we get wrong and don't seem to have a good understanding of as a nation. What better time to revisit this than now, as we celebrate or commemorate the 250th anniversary?

Ongoing thread. More from Robert P. Watson to follow.
Curator: Bora Pajo
April 3, 2026

Watson, Robert P. Declaration: The Story of American Independence. Bloomsbury Academic, 2026. ISBN 979-8216371557

Robert P. Watson

Robert Watson has published nearly 50 books and 200 scholarly articles and essays on topics in political, military, and social history, as well as two multi-edition, multi-volume encyclopedia sets on the presidents and first ladies. Some of his recent books include Affairs of State (Rowman & Littlefield, 2012), America’s First Crisis (SUNY Press, 2014), The Nazi Titanic (Hachette, 2016), The Ghost Ship of Brooklyn (Hachette, 2017), George Washington’s Final Battle (Georgetown University Press, 2021), Escape! (Rowman & Littlefield, 2021), When Washington Burned (Georgetown University Press, 2023), American’s First Plague (Rowman & Littlefield, 2023), Rebels at the Gates (Rowman & Littlefield, 2025), and two forthcoming books: Declaration: The Story of American Independence (Bloomsbury, 2026) and The Trump Presidency (SUNY Press, 2026). A few of Watson’s books have won national awards, are in foreign translation, and have been featured at literary festivals, on PBS and C-SPAN, and in television documentaries.

Support this awesome media project

We don't have paywalls. We don't sell your data. Please help to keep this running!