The Nature of Nurture - A close-up

Consider the following facts: some adolescents—males and females--are more sexually active than many others; some adults have multiple unstable intimate relationships; some adults are not particularly involved, devoted, or caring parents. We have long thought of such individuals as “fallen”, behaving as they do either because they are genetically disposed to or because their childhoods led them to develop these ways. But what evolution teaches us, whether we like it or not, is that these ways of developing reflect the fact that in our species’ evolutionary past it made good sense to develop these ways because it increased chances of reproducing.

And by the same token, we should not simply attribute individuals developing and functioning in the opposite way as simply because they had good rearing or were born that way. In fact, one implication of the book’s central arguments is that no matter the trait or feature of an individual under consideration, some not so highly susceptible to effects of early-life experiences were “born” that way, but that others developing in exactly the same way were “made” that way! Thus, knowing how a person develops does not tell you whether nature or nurture were principally responsible because the same way of developing can be the result of different causal influences.  Thus, some really nice and some really nasty people were made that way, others were born that way! 

Curator: Bora Pajo
April 29, 2026

Belsky, Jay. The Nature of Nurture: Rethinking Why and How Childhood Adversity Shapes Development. Belknap Press, 2026. ISBN 9780674303966

Jay Belsky

Jay Belsky is Emeritus Professor Human Development at the University of California, Davis (2011-present), having stepped down from the Robert M. and Natalie Reid Dorn Professorship before retiring in 2022. He is the author of more than 500 scholarly articles and chapters, including serving as author/editor of five books. Professor Belsky obtained his Ph.D. in 1978 in Human Development and Family Studies from Cornell University. Thereafter he served on the faculty at Penn State University and Birkbeck University of London. Professor Belsky is an internationally recognized expert in the field of child development and family studies. His areas of special expertise include effects of day care, parent-child relations and other developmental experiences and environmental exposures early in life on psychological and behavioral development, the transition to parenthood, the etiology of child maltreatment and the evolutionary basis of parent and child functioning. He was named among the 200 Eminent Psychologists of the Modern Era in 2014 (Archives of Scientific Psychology); in 2015 listed among the top 100 “Greatest Living Behavioral and Brain Scientists” ; and in 2019/2025 among the top 0.01% of all scientists based on impact (PLoS Biology, Ioannidis et al.).

Support this awesome media project

We don't have paywalls. We don't sell your data. Please help to keep this running!