
Hugh B. Urban
Mysticism without religion, and the fungus that made it possible.
One of the most remarkable episodes in the modern history of psychedelics and religion was the “Marsh Chapel Experiment” (aka “Good Friday Experiment”) held in the basement of Boston University’s Marsh Chapel in 1962. The experiment was led by Walter Pahnke, a minister, psychiatrist and PhD student at Harvard, who was also working with the infamous Harvard psychologist, Timothy Leary. Held during the Good Friday service with the audio piped in, the experiment involved twenty students, half of whom were given a placebo and half given a capsule containing psilocybin. Significantly, the experiment also included ten “guides” to help oversee and facilitate the experiment; but they too participated in the psilocybin trial, with half taking the actual drug. The results of the research became the basis for Pahnke’s dissertation, “Drugs and Mysticism,” which claimed to have found a way to reliably produce and study genuine mystical experiences in a scientific way “under laboratory conditions.” The dissertation also included a quantitative scale for evaluating the spiritual experiences, which later became the basis for the “Mystical Experience Questionnaire” (MEQ) – a version of which is still widely used in psychedelic research to this day. Despite (or perhaps because of) the obvious flaws in his research methodology and analytical assumptions, Pahnke’s work and his mysticism scale have informed more or less all psychedelic research over the last 60 years and are still widely cited in psilocybin trials coming out of Johns Hopkins and other major universities today.
Curator: Bora Pajo

Urban, H. B. (2026). Still seeking the magic mushroom: Fungi, pharmaceuticals, and mysticism without religion. University of Chicago Press.
Available here →November 20, 2026
20261120-urban-still-seeking-the-magic-mushroom-a-close-up
A close-up

Hugh B. Urban is an Arts and Sciences Distinguished Professor in the Department of Comparative Studies at the Ohio State University. His work focuses on religions of South Asia and new religious movements in the United States. He is the author of numerous books and articles, including Tantra: Sex, Secrecy, Politics, and Power in the Study of Religion (2003); The Church of Scientology: A History of a New Religion (2011); Secrecy: Silence, Power and Religion (2021); and Still Seeking the Magic Mushroom: Fungi, Pharmaceuticals, and Mysticism without Religion (2026).
Most threads on Rorotoko begin with our invitation. Any thread can begin with a proposal: you write it with the same prompts every thread answers, and we review it.
Propose a thread →